Evidence in an Age of Doubt
Courts have long treated audio and video recordings as among the most persuasive forms of proof. The camera, it was assumed, does not lie. Deepfakes have shattered that assumption in two directions at once. A fabricated recording may be offered as genuine to incriminate an innocent person; and, perhaps more insidiously, a genuine recording may be dismissed as a deepfake by a guilty one. Scholars call this second phenomenon the liar’s dividend: the mere possibility of fabrication becomes a shield against authentic evidence. The law of evidence must now equip judges to navigate both dangers.
The Statutory Framework
The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 places electronic records firmly within the law of evidence. Section 61 provides that the admissibility of an electronic record shall not be denied merely on the ground that it is electronic. Section 63 governs the admissibility of electronic records as documents and, in Section 63(4), requires a certificate in the form prescribed in the Schedule to the Act. Significantly, that form is in two parts: Part A to be completed by the party producing the record, and Part B by an expert, with details of the device and the hash value of the record, a digital fingerprint that reveals whether a file has been altered.
This structure builds on hard won jurisprudence under Section 65B of the former Indian Evidence Act. In Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer (2014), the Supreme Court held that secondary electronic evidence is admissible only with the required certificate, and in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal (2020), a three judge bench affirmed that the certificate is a condition precedent to admissibility. The new law’s insistence on expert participation and hash values is a welcome response to an era in which authenticity can no longer be presumed.
Why Certification Is Not Enough
A certificate establishes how a record was produced and preserved; it cannot, on its own, establish that the content was never synthetically generated before it reached the device. Courts will therefore need to rely increasingly on forensic examination: analysis of metadata, compression artefacts, lighting and audio inconsistencies, and provenance information such as embedded content credentials. The 2026 amendments to the IT Rules, which require labels and provenance metadata on synthetically generated information, may in time become valuable evidentiary aids. Section 79A of the IT Act, which provides for notified Examiners of Electronic Evidence, deserves far greater capacity and use.
Recommendations
- Preserve original files and devices, and record hash values at the earliest moment of seizure.
- Train judges, prosecutors and defence lawyers in the fundamentals of synthetic media detection.
- Expand the network of notified Examiners of Electronic Evidence and accredited forensic laboratories.
- Develop judicial guidelines on the burden of proof when authenticity is disputed on grounds of fabrication.
Conclusion
Justice depends on the court’s ability to separate truth from artifice. In the deepfake era, that ability can no longer rest on instinct or on the apparent realism of a recording. It must rest on rigorous procedure, scientific scrutiny and a legal culture that treats authenticity not as an assumption, but as a matter to be proved.
